Doctor's Note

Please feel free to post any ask-the-doctor type questions here in the comments section and I’d be happy to try to answer them. And check out the other videos on spices. Also, there are 1,449 other subjects covered in the rest of my videos--please feel free to explore them as well!

For some context, please check out my associated blog posts: Countering Dietary Pollutants & PesticidesBest Dried Fruit For Cholesterol , and Cinnamon for Diabetes

  • Michael Greger M.D.

    Please feel free to post any ask-the-doctor type questions here in the comments section and I’d be happy to try to answer them. And check out the other videos on spices. Also, there are 1,449 other subjects covered in the rest of my videos–please feel free to explore them as well!

  • becochic

    You can also run some pecans through your food processor and use the pecan flour for a crust!

    • Michael Greger M.D.

      That sounds so delicious–I’m totally going to try that. Thank you so much for the tip becochic!

      • http://www.facebook.com/ryanseaton Ryan 船 Seaton

        Are there any alternatives for soy-phobic people ? I love soy however ….

        • Synergy

          It probably won’t be of any consolation to you, but the latest research suggests soy is health promoting. Earlier studies involving animal models did not translate to humans. The “anti-nutrient” phytic acid now turns out to have anti-cancer properties (and is a non-issue for anyone eating a varied, adequate diet). Likewise, the phytoestrogens in soy have not only been shown to be metabolized differently than real estrogen (such as that in cows milk), in humans as opposed to rats, but have shown a wide array of anti-cancer effects, including cancers instigated by sex hormones such as estrogen! It is easy to see why there would be such an effort to discredit a versatile meat/dairy alternative with a verified “complete” amino acid profile. Follow the money!

          • http://www.facebook.com/ryanseaton Ryan 船 Seaton

            Wow. I need to check my disqus replies more often. The anti-soy lobby frequently cites GMO foods as another reason to avoid soy. I’m glad the latest research is vindicating soy for which there are so many pros and cons re soy protein isolate vs whole organic soy etc

          • Synergy

            I do, but not based on any specific evidence. There is concern over hexane during processing, but the dose makes the poison. Assuming hexane studies on mice bare resemblance to human metabolism of the toxin (whereas the aforementioned infamous studies on soy did not), you would have to eat several thousand veggie burgers a day, every day, in order for complications to arise. You couldn’t do that if you tried. I’m not sure how much protein powder it would be equivalent to, though.

            I have the occasional boca burger, but it’s always a good guideline to stick as close to whole foods as possible. The less chemical toxins, the better.

          • Synergy

            Three additional considerations:

            1. Many people have a soy allergy. As with wheat, such allergies make soy an easy target for criticism. If you are not allergic, studies have demonstrated that soy can be very beneficial.

            2. Soy does in fact contain goitrogenic compounds, but so does broccoli and flax. It should not be an issue as long as your iodine intake is optimal.

            3. Possibly because it is a complete protein, soy can influence IGF-1, which is implicated in cancer primarily in relation to animal protein. But you need to consume a lot of soy products for this to happen. 3-5 servings a day should be safe.

            Look up “avoiding iodine deficiency” and “how much soy is too much” via the search function at the top right.

          • http://www.facebook.com/ryanseaton Ryan 船 Seaton

            Thanks for the enlightening informative commentary . I have a note discussing the pros and cons of Soy on facebook and I wouldn’t mind if you dropped by to share commentary, particularly the 21 or so objections that Eden Soy and others had to defend . https://www.facebook.com/notes/ryan-oneil-船-seaton/soy-pros-and-cons-abstention-moderation-/10150105574096801 . Message me on facebook if you can . Best Regards .

    • Vera Springate

      I bet almond meal – left after straining homemade almond milk – will work too. 

  • tokyovegan

    Dear Micheal.
    Speaking of pumpkins…
    How about roasting and eating the pumpkin seeds? Are they healthy for you (with very little added oil or salt)
    Thanks,
    William
    PS–I love your site and keep introducing people to it. THANK YOU!

    • Toxins

      Hello Tokyovegan,

      check out this video on food absorption.
      http://nutritionfacts.org/videos/raw-food-nutrient-absorption-2/

      It appears roasting almonds increased the ability for the nutrients to be absorbed by your body. Perhaps the same is true with pumpkin seeds? I cannot give you a definitive answer but it seems likely so.

  • http://www.facebook.com/kbase147 Kathleen Bass

    Me and my Gma are doing this for Thanksgiving! (she doesnt know its helthy ;))

  • BPCveg

    I was excited to try and make this pie, but where on earth can you get a healthy pie crust? Every store I have checked sells nothing but junk!

    • http://twitter.com/jimarnold jim arnold

      I found spelt and whole wheat pie crusts at my local store that traffics in higher end organic foods. I’ve made two of these pies now. Tasty and easy. Thanks!

    • Dave

      Late to the party, but try this:

      http://caloriecount.about.com/low-calorie-pie-crust-recipe-r755980

      Ingredients:
      Whole Wheat Flour, 1/2 cup
      Salt,1/8 tsp (remove)
      Olive Oil, 1 tbsp (remove)
      Cold water, 4 tbsp

      Directions:
      Mix ingredients in the order listed and knead into a ball. Refridgerate well (15 minutes). Roll using a floured surface and rolling pin. Place in 9″ pie pan and prick bottom with fork several times. Bake at 450 dgrees F for 10 minutes before filling. Makes 6 servings.

      Great thing about this — crust is done right when you’re done making the ingredients for the filling! Pie done in under an hour :-)

      Or do what I do — go crustless :-)

  • euromixer

    For a healthy pie crust what about making your own out of whole foods: In a food processor (so much for whole foods :) grind up some walnuts, or pecans as noted above. toss in 5-6 pitted dates or use some date syrup. Maybe a dash of cinnamon and vanilla till it begins to stick together like a ball in the processor. Place in bottom of pie dish… and you just made a beautiful crust

    • BPCveg

      Thanks for the idea. Certainly worth a try!

    • BPCveg

      Dear Euromixer,
      Thank you so much for your excellent suggestion for a healthful pie crust recipe. It turned out to be delicious.

      Just a note that I found the general recipe to be effective even without using nutmeg, which can be a controversial ingredient due to psychoactive properties (I wouldn’t want to get high on my pie).

  • michaelresanders

    I have always just eaten the pumpkin with cinnamon and the other spices stirred in — most of the time I don’t even heat it. So I don’t need to make a pie; instead, a pudding. (It also makes for a nice pumpkin smoothie if you put the pumpkin, spices, and two bananas in a Vitamix and let it rip until warm. I usually have this for breakfast.

  • Megan

    I was wondering if you had any information about the antioxidant power of ginger- I did a juice fast a while ago and I put ginger in some of my apple juice and the apple juice with ginger stayed a lovely green color (granny smith apples) while the juice without the ginger turned brown. The juice that just had a tiny bit of ginger left from my combined juice still stayed green. I am not a scientist but I figured the apples turn brown from contact with oxygen, so could the ginger be protective? It isn’t on your list of high antioxidant foods. 

  • LuccaQ

    Garam masala! It has all of these spices and then some. Grind it yourself though, the taste is infinitely superior. There are many variations on the recipe. I prefer a Gujarati garam masala by Julie Sahni for its balanced and herbaceous flavor.

  • Andrea

    Unfortunately, NOT so healthy for those of us with soy allergy. Ideas to replace the tofu, anyone? Thanks in advance for your creativity!

  • Occams_Razor

    I have been making the Dr. McDougall pumpkin pie for several years now (also based on pumpkin and tofu), but this sounds even easier and really good.

    However, their crust is really good, for those who can eat nuts. It’s raw cashews (2/3 c) ground in a food processor, with some (1-1/2c.) flour, 3 T Sucanat sugar, a bit of vanilla and salt, and 4 T. now-unavailable Wonderslim Fat Replacer. But Wonderslim was just prunes, water and oat bran, and prunes blended in a skoshie of water with some applesauce works just as well. It’s sweet, so any other sweetener is up to you.

    I found it was a lot less painful to blend only the dry cashews in the blender, and mix the wet stuff in in a bowl. Otherwise, your blender gets to keep most of it.

  • Katie

    I was curious as to about how much of each spice to add? Thanks!

  • Janice Wilton

    An April 2013 video noted that nutmeg may have a narrow safety margin. I was surprised to see it listed as a spice in the pumpkin pie that Dr. Greger would us as much as possible as I know the other spices are very anti-oxidant rich. Since reading the “nutmeg” video, I have stopped using although I use cinnamon, ginger and especially cloves liberally since I have learned from Dr. Greger, the high anti-oxidant value of these spices.

  • diane

    Is this recipe for pumpkin pie printed out anywhere?

    • foxfyr

      Expand the article by clicking on the “sources cited” and “transcript” links above!Then cut and paste it into Word or equivalent.

  • Kathleen Graas

    Use freshly-baked butternut squasg, instead of canned pumpkin…you will NOT regret it!

    • Kathleen Graas

      squash no squasg

  • Marie Lankford

    With all the hype regarding health benefits of juicing wheat grass, are there any concerns we should consider in consuming the juice?

  • Aimee

    Ani Phyo has good raw dessert recipes. My pumpkin pie crust is based on her books. I use raw pumpkin seeds with dates for the crust. If you line the pie plate with wax paper, it will come out a little prettier. My family is ok with the pile that can result otherwise. The taste is what counts for them!

  • dave

    I fooled my girlfriend… after she ate a slice, I told her there was tofu in there… she was shocked!

    Now, how much is too much spices?
    I put about 2 tsp of cinnamon, and a 1 tsp each of ginger, clove, and nutmeg… and it comes out perfect!
    I wonder can we get away with more?