Toxins in Cooked Potatoes?

Toxins in Cooked Potatoes?
3.56 (71.11%) 36 votes

Natural glycoalkaloid toxins concentrate in the skins of potatoes.

Discuss
Republish

Any other natural toxins to consider? Well, potatoes produce these natural insecticide compounds called glycoalkaloids to keep potato beetles from nibbling on them—they’re not stupid. So, bad for beetles though—but what about us?

Well, a number of dietary risk assessments have been published lately, and although these glycoalkaloids are thought to be the most highly consumed natural toxin in North America, people have been growing potatoes for 7,000 years—currently the fourth largest food crop in the world.

Major review just published; what do you think? Now, this is for a baked potato—not fried, no butter, no cheese, no sour cream, no salt. Just a plain baked potato. Bad? Neither? Or good?

Well, we already know they’re not good, from before. But true safety, or false sense of security? Asking the question of “vital importance,” are potato glycoalkaloids dangerous to humans? This discussion suggests they are indeed toxic, and this problem should no longer be ignored. Okay, then.

To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video. This is just an approximation of the audio contributed by veganmontreal.

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Any other natural toxins to consider? Well, potatoes produce these natural insecticide compounds called glycoalkaloids to keep potato beetles from nibbling on them—they’re not stupid. So, bad for beetles though—but what about us?

Well, a number of dietary risk assessments have been published lately, and although these glycoalkaloids are thought to be the most highly consumed natural toxin in North America, people have been growing potatoes for 7,000 years—currently the fourth largest food crop in the world.

Major review just published; what do you think? Now, this is for a baked potato—not fried, no butter, no cheese, no sour cream, no salt. Just a plain baked potato. Bad? Neither? Or good?

Well, we already know they’re not good, from before. But true safety, or false sense of security? Asking the question of “vital importance,” are potato glycoalkaloids dangerous to humans? This discussion suggests they are indeed toxic, and this problem should no longer be ignored. Okay, then.

To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video. This is just an approximation of the audio contributed by veganmontreal.

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Doctor's Note

If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my videos for free by clicking here.

77 responses to “Toxins in Cooked Potatoes?

Comment Etiquette

On NutritionFacts.org, you'll find a vibrant community of nutrition enthusiasts, health professionals, and many knowledgeable users seeking to discover the healthiest diet to eat for themselves and their families. As always, our goal is to foster conversations that are insightful, engaging, and most of all, helpful – from the nutrition beginners to the experts in our community.

To do this we need your help, so here are some basic guidelines to get you started.

The Short List

To help maintain and foster a welcoming atmosphere in our comments, please refrain from rude comments, name-calling, and responding to posts that break the rules (see our full Community Guidelines for more details). We will remove any posts in violation of our rules when we see it, which will, unfortunately, include any nicer comments that may have been made in response.

Be respectful and help out our staff and volunteer health supporters by actively not replying to comments that are breaking the rules. Instead, please flag or report them by submitting a ticket to our help desk. NutritionFacts.org is made up of an incredible staff and many dedicated volunteers that work hard to ensure that the comments section runs smoothly and we spend a great deal of time reading comments from our community members.

Have a correction or suggestion for video or blog? Please contact us to let us know. Submitting a correction this way will result in a quicker fix than commenting on a thread with a suggestion or correction.

View the Full Community Guidelines

  1. New (as-yet-unpublished) study evidently suggests that the consumption of purple potatoes may significantly improve blood pressure of overweight and obese individuals. If you choose to continue to eat potatoes, choose the varieties with colored flesh (though I suspect that sweet potatoes still remain healthier overall).

    1. I prefer the light sweet potatoes and almost don’t like the dark ones at all. I would love to hear that my choice is a good one and fits in your statement of remaining healthier overall. Hmm?

  2. I believe for a variety of reasons (incredible nutritional profile, lower glycemic index, edible raw or cooked) that sweet potatoes – a staple of many long-lived cultures – should always be consumed over potatoes.

  3. Does this include all potatoes that are not sweet potatoes – even like Yukon golds and red skins and purple potatoes? (I saw your post about purple and blood pressure, and I don’t need to lower my blood pressure).

    1. The healthiest potatoes are probably sweet potatoes (see my video about sweet potatoes), but if you are going to eat plain potatoes, the varieties with colored flesh (not just skin) do appear healthier. A new study published this month found that the consumption of 6-8 microwaved purple potatoes a day (they’re pretty small) resulted in a boost in antioxidant capacity of the blood (whereas the plain potato starch control acted as a pro-oxidant) and a drop in blood pressure in overweight individuals. “Thus,” they concluded, “purple potatoes are an effective hypotensive agent and lower the risk of heart disease and stroke in hypertensive subjects without weight gain.” Last year a study found that purple potatoes appeared to suppress both early and late stage human colon cancer cells in vitro, but only if they were fresh. After being in storage a few months their anti-cancer properties diminished. And finally, another study published last year (and this one available full-text), found a trend towards lower inflammation in men eating purple potatoes than white, concluding “Pigmented potato consumption reduced inflammation and DNA damage in healthy adult males. This offers consumers an improved nutritional choice in potato consumption.” Purple sweet potatoes may offer the best of both worlds, as suggested in an in vitro study last year on human fat cells that suggested anti-obesity, anti-oxidant, and anti-inflammatory benefits.

  4. »The healthiest potatoes are probably sweet potatoes (see my video about sweet potatoes), but if you are going to eat plain potatoes, the varieties with colored flesh (not just skin) do appear healthier«

    Oh yes, but your video tells me that the »normal« potatoe, I – and untold millions – eat, is harmful. I can hardly believe that!

    1. What does it prove that “untold millions” eat them? Especially since the vast majority in the Western world don’t eat nearly as healthy as a WFPB diet.
      Besides that, you can practically survive beyond age 100 while eating harmful things, but there’s a great distinction between maximizing health and merely surviving. Plus, if it’s the only questionable food you’re eating, your health risks are probably already a lot lower than the average Western person anyway.

  5. Do you think the levels would be insignificant in potatoes that were entirely or almost entirely free of green. Some suggest we just need to be more careful with storing them (farmers that is). I would agree that even slightly green potatoes you should say no to though and there are better choices of course.

  6. I follow your reports closely and this has to be one of your most questionable positions. White potatoes harmful. You should know that in John McDougall’s latest book “The Starch Solution” he cites white and sweet potatoes as the most nearly perfect foods, very early in the book. He claims these two foods each alone could sustain human life (add b12) fairly well. So, next to nixing avocados 86ing the white potatoes leaves me feeling quite doubtful. And the problem with raising such doubt on a few items with viewers like me is that it forces me to reduce my level of confidence slightly in all of your statements. I suspect another example is your positive view on cocoa. This food can be quite dangerous to some animals (dogs, for example). And it’s clearly “the rage” in health food stores now. A fad? So, maybe it’s time to cut cocoa down a few notches by comparing it head-to-head with carob. Please? Anyway. I wish you would have another category for evaluating foods: The jury is still out ( or uncertain). Placing a harmful rating on some foods is a very difficult proposition!

    1. I am also in disagreement with Dr. Greger’s view on white potatoes, while I still do not eat avacados for more complex reasons. Potatoes are quite nutrient dense and satiating,

      http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/vegetables-and-vegetable-products/2770/2

      I think the main issue that we find in studies are that potatoes are lumped together with french fries or potato chips which are the least bit healthful.

      Jeff Novick really cuts into the potato concern quite well here.

      https://www.facebook.com/notes/jeff-novick-ms-rd/potatoes-diabetes-dietary-trends-truths-about-taters/434650191818

      1. I appreciated your post especially the link to Jeff Novick’s facebook notes which is excellent. I have found the nutritiondata website useful as well for looking up details. I was surprised to see the amount of Vitamin C and Folate in 300 grams of a white potato. I was surprised to see that it is listed as an inflammatory food as it is primarily starch (i.e glucose) and very little fructose. I wasn’t surprised that I couldn’t ferret out the details of the equations used to calculate the number… sorry my undergraduate training as a chemical engineer drives me to the equation before I put any credence in a number whether that is the Inflammatory Factor on nutritiondata or Nutrient Density in Whole Foods. If you look at the ratio of Omega 6/3 it is about 4/1 which is acceptable. Toxins… thanks again for the post.

      1. I remember reading once that it was ok to eat skin if boiled but not if baked, but I can’t find that report now. So looking for new info on it.

    1. According to FoodSafetyWatch.org (http://www.foodsafetywatch.org/factsheets/glycoalkaloids/) “In normal tubers, potato glycoalkaloids appear to be concentrated in a small 1.5 mm layer immediately under the skin, therefore, with normal tubers, peeling will remove between 60% – 95% of the glycoalkaloids present.”
      But since their is a higher concentration of nutrients in the skin, one is in effect throwing the metaphorical baby out with the bath water nutritionally speaking. The article goes on to say that potatoes that are high in glycoalkaloid toxin, the green and sprouting ones, have a greater percentage of the toxin in the flesh, and that the glycoalkaloids are heat stable until the very high cooking temperatures found in deep frying which impart their own set of problems.

  7. So, it’s pretty easy for me to peel my cooked Yukon Golds, the Russets are a little harder and I can’t see peeling a baked pot. To think that I used to eat the skins and not the insides. Anyway, are baked even good for us at all? I’m just about ready to get my new stove put in and dying to bake up a big batch of baked potatoes. Hmmm. Should I give up the dream?

  8. Ann Med. 2013 Nov;45(7):467-73. doi: 10.3109/07853890.2013.813633. Epub 2013 Jul 15.

    The role of potatoes and potato components in cardiometabolic health: A review.

    McGill CR, Kurilich AC, Davignon J.

    Source

    Healthy Science Communications, LLC.

    Abstract

    Abstract Potatoes (Solanum tuberosum) are an important food crop worldwide and contribute key nutrients to the diet, including vitamin C, potassium, and dietary fiber. Potatoes and potato components have been shown to have favorable impacts on several measures of cardiometabolic health in animals and humans, including lowering blood pressure, improving lipid profiles, and decreasing markers of inflammation. A range of glycemic index (GI) values have been reported for potatoes, and data are sparse regarding the impact of potato consumption on the postprandial glycemic response, especially when potatoes are consumed with other foods. There is a lack of clinical trial data regarding the impact of potatoes on weight management. A small number of human cohort studies have reported beneficial associations between potato consumption as part of a healthy lifestyle and cardiometabolic health. Another small number of human population studies have included potatoes as part of a dietary pattern with other calorie-dense foods and have not reported cardiometabolic benefits. The epidemiological literature should be interpreted with caution due to lack of consistency in both defining dietary patterns that include potatoes and in control for potential confounding variables. Controlled clinical trials are needed to define the impact of potatoes on cardiometabolic health.

  9. This has to be the one report on this site that is most likely to be WRONG. Really wish we could get some solid information on eating white potatoes. So many resources say that they are a great food. And Dr Greger says they aren’t based on this one study? or are there many studies supporting his ADVICE here?

    1. Dr. Gregor is just reporting a study that he found. I didn’t hear him advise against eating potatoes at all if we want to.
      When I read the report from source #2 listed, I interpreted that the toxins are released by potatoes in response to beetle infestation and the toxins are in higher amounts in raw unpeeled potatoes.
      I suggest that we all check the sources he points us toward and then make our own decision.

  10. I have a better chance of finding diamonds in my backyard than finding purple potatoes in ANY store around me. They are the one food nobody carries!? Not whole foods… not mothers market… no place in Southern California carries purples… I’d make the switch if I could find them as I love red potatoes and eat them every day, practically every meal as suggested by our good friend Dr. John McDougall. If I ever go on one of those health cruises. I’m going to strait up ask both Dr.’s to stand up and debate over our beloved white or red potato. (I hope McDougall wins). =)

  11. I’m not sure about the conclusions on the harms of the white potatoe. When I went to the sources cited, one study was a model, and the other was based on testing on hamsters. Perhaps the evidence is pointing away from the healthiness of white potatoes, but these conclusions seem to be based on weak data. I have to admit, I didn’t read the whole articles, just access to the free text (in this case, Abstracts only).

  12. Perhaps the study points toward toxicity because potatoes belong to the notorious Deadly Nightshade family. Many people react to foods belonging in this family group. There is always good information to had on this site that is always backed up by research and peer reviews. Thank you Dr. Greger.

  13. I have been told that the glycoalkaloids in potatoes are due to solanine, in green parts of the potato, and they can be eaten safely as long as there are they are kept in the dark, there are no deep green parts, and any green on the skin is discarded. What do you think?

  14. Potatoes contain glycoalkaloids which are toxic to humans but have a generally accepted safe level (200 mg/kg). Glycoalkaloids also are not cleared from the body in 24 hrs so they may accumulate if eaten regularly. Glycoalkaloid safe levels are considered “safe” because they don’t usually cause acute problems at that level (although I did read one anecdote of someone throwing up at the 200 mg/kg quantity). However, the potential for long term problems were not tested, so long term safety is unknown. All of this can be found in Pub Med.
    If they seem safe because a lot of people are eating them, you might want to rethink that. A lot of people are eating cheeseburgers, too. I think potatoes, blue or otherwise, deserve to be in the suspect food category due to Glycoalkaloids. If they are eaten at all, it should be rarely or occasionally.

    1. Yes a lot of people are eating cheeseburgers, but those people are having heart attacks and as consumption of dairy and meat increases, so do rates of chronic disease. On the other hand, a lot of people eat potatoes (there have even been reports of people living healthfully for months on nothing but potatoes and water) and there has never been a case of potato-induced toxicity or cancer rates in line with… potato consumption. In Ireland, the population doubled when potatoes were introduced to the diet. I’m a vegan now and was a vegetarian most of my life, so I can’t recollect how I felt after a cheeseburger, but I definitely didn’t feel so good after eating cheese. I’ve eaten lots of potatoes and never once have I experienced any ill effects.

      1. “In Ireland, the population doubled when potatoes were introduced to the diet.”

        This is true. The capital has been Dublin ever since.

  15. Abstract
    Send to:

    J Agric Food Chem. 2000 Jun;48(6):2472-5.
    High-performance
    liquid chromatographic determination of the glycoalkaloids
    alpha-solanine and alpha-chaconine in 12 commercial varieties of Mexican
    potato.
    Sotelo A1, Serrano B.
    Author information
    Abstract
    The
    glycoalkaloid content in 12 commercial varieties of Mexican potatoes
    was measured by HPLC in both the peel and the flesh of the potato. The
    principal glycoalkaloids alpha-solanine and alpha-chaconine were present
    in higher concentration in the peel than in the flesh of all varieties.
    The main alkaloid in the peel of the potatoes was alpha-chaconine and
    comprised about 65-71% of the total glycoalkaloids. The high
    concentration of alpha-chaconine in peel, which is more toxic than
    alpha-solanine, gives more protection to the tuber against predators.
    The total alkaloids in the peel of Alpha, Juanita, Michoacan, Norteña,
    Rosita, and Tollocan varieties were higher than the limit recommended
    for food safety. However, the peel represents less than 10% of the total
    tuber in most of the varieties. The total alkaloids contained in the
    peel of Atzimba, Lopez, Marciana, Montsama, Murca, and Puebla was lower
    than the limits recommended for food safety. The glycoalkaloid content
    in the boiled peeled potatoes was less than 9 mg/100 g but in Alpha,
    Montsama, and Puebla varieties, both glycoalkaloids were absent.
    According to the results, the consumption of the 12 commercial varieties
    of Mexican potatoes does not represent any danger to human health.

  16. I have only found studies exploring the short term effects, like this one: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15649828. It seems the alkaloids have gastro-intestinal and systemic effects. But what are the long term effects? Obviously, anyone can notice the immediate effects of poisoning, so the main worry is about the long term effects. Are there any studies exploring those? Or are there any expected effects? Thanks!

  17. Jeff Novick published many recipes that contain plain potatos,

    I hardly believe he would use them, if they really that bad to our health.

    1. He also critically debunked the glycoalkaloid issue and I really think Dr G NEEDS to update his take on taters because the proof of harm is not there and creates judgmental concerns on the reductionist approach it favors.

      1. I would be interested in an update, as well. Seven years, and Dr. Greger’s nuanced development of his views mean a great deal of editing ahead, Thankfully, Greger is now a “free agent”, theoretically with more time to budget to this very task.

        Not by coincidence, the calls for volunteers have increased, the best index the whole foods, plant-based diet has gained an order-of-magnitude in traction in that same seven years. Many prospective but glycoalkaloid-averse potato eaters are among them.

  18. my understanding of regular potatoes any color skin flesh etc. is this…potatoes are on the dirty dozen list…sweet potatoes are on the clean 15…i eat over 50% of my diet in the form of a few different colors of sweet potatoes…i buy them bulk…peel ’em very deeply…at least 1/2 inch all around…i sometimes get them as large as 6 pounds(football sized)…i used to wear out the regular potatoes but after speaking with the safety expert from a huge potato company to find out if the potatoes are grown on soil which had grain crops treated with round-up herbicide filled with atrazine and glyphosate(which most grain crops are…inluding many wheat crops…they get sprayed like 3 days before harvest…then the round-up is in the soil)…problem is…the round-up stays for 7 years…after stayin’ off the soil for a couple years…it can have any kind of crop planted on it and get an organic rating…but…whatever was planted on that soil is then full of round-up…so…this crop rotation onto fields which had grain crops sprayed with round-up herbicide etc. is EXTREMELY COMMON IN THE GROWING PRACTICE FOR REGULAR POTATOES…very common practice…so even if you peel ’em deeply…they are still soaked with round-up…the glyphosates get in the gut…the aluminum which is all over everything grown above ground and not covered(hot house etc)…gets eaten9ya can’t wash it off…unless ya peel everything…but greens etc. ya can not get it out…it gets in the fiber)…then ya eat it…it goes in the gut…mixes with the glyphosate…becomes 10,000 timesmore toxic…inhibits the bodies ability to properly process sulfur into sulfide and sulfate…basically many very smart researchers are sayin’ this is the cause of all this asperger’s…autism…alzheimer’s like symptoms in the elderly…you can only take so much nano…pico…and heavy metal poisoning…the brain starts to act very strangely…so…long story short…i eat lots of sweet pots grown on clean soil…they are non-gmo and basically grown organically…but…the grower doesn’t pay for the certification…i make sure to get my omega 3 from fresh ground flax seed in the morning away from my sweet potato consumption…the omega 6 in the sweet pots inhibits the absorption of omega 3 and i only want so much fat daily…i’m on the heart attack proof diet by dr. caldwell b. esselstyn jr….tryin’ to remove more omega 6 from my sweet pots…peel ’em deeply…cut ’em thin…soak in distilled(thirsty…negatively charged water)…it bonds with inorganic positively charged minerals and almost all toxins are positively charged…fukushima daiichi fallout(plus the over 2000 nuclear weapons which have been tested and all the power plant leaks and meltdowns etc.)…anyway…i soak the super thin sweet potato pieces dump the hopefully filled up with toxins soak water…then boil my thin sweets in new distilled water…hope this is removing a bunch of the omega 6…not sure however…anyway…no regular potatoes for me…just sayin. this is how i roll…lol…hope this helps…

  19. Wait, so you are saying that regular white potatoes are unhealthy even when eating in its whole version. I am so confused? This does not make sense. Please clarify in more detail? Thanks :)

    1. Daniel: The video following this video is helpful in answering your question: http://nutritionfacts.org/video/toxins-in-sweet-potatoes/ It tells about a safer way to eat plain potatoes.
      .
      Also, keep in mind that this is an older video. I don’t speak for Dr. Greger, but based on what I have read and heard from him more recently, I would guess that Dr. Greger would phrase his conclusions with a lot more nuance if he did such a video today. It’s not so much good or bad, but more about “relative to what”. A baked white potato is a whole lot healthier to eat than say white bread or french fries. On the other hand, a white potato is not nearly as healthy as sweet potatoes. What are your choices? If your choice is between a sweet potato and a white one, choose the sweet. But if your choice is between a white potato and white bread, choose the white potato.
      .
      In his book, How Not To Die, on page 328, Dr. Greger writes, “Sweet potatoes are healthier than plain potatoes, but if you’re going to choose the latter, seek out those with blue or purple flesh. The consumption of one boiled purple potato a day for six weeks was found to significantly decrease inflammation, something neither white nor yellow potatoes were able to accomplish.”
      .
      Hope that helps!

      1. Hey Thea. Thank you so much for the answer. Currently i am trying to eat a whole foods plant based diet. Avoiding oil, sugar etc. I only eat whole grain rice, pasta and bread. I ve heard his “healthy, relative to what?” argument and i understand it. Even tho there must be a way of saying if something is health promoting or not without having it to compare to something even healthier or worse for you. My question or worry now is that white regular potatoes are not health promoting but even disease promoting, which i take from this video? I understand that they are not as nutrtious as purple sweet potatoes but one should be able to say if they do a body good or not, right? I really appreciate your time input here :)

        1. Daniel: re: “Even tho there must be a way of saying if something is health promoting or not…” I agree with you to a degree. For example, surely we can all agree that say bacon is unhealthy? Surely there is a line in the sand somewhere from which we can say that food X is healthy or not? I believe that’s both true and untrue. I’m still working on articulating my thoughts in this area. I just wanted to share that I get your point.
          .
          To get to your bottom line question: I don’t think I’m qualified to answer it. I’m not an expert in general and I don’t have enough knowledge to have an authoritative opinion on this subject. I can say that same question you have has plagued me since the video on this page came out. After much thinking and listening more to Dr. Greger and others, my opinion (but again, just my guess, not an authoritative answer) is that the concern raised in this video is not a big one. I’ve heard that Dr. McDougall thinks that plain white potatoes are very healthy. And as Dr. Greger even points out, there have been entire societies that have lived on white potatoes. Though not blue zones I don’t think…
          .
          For myself, I have decided that white potatoes should not be the basis of my diet, but are a perfectly healthy to have from time to time without any guilt or concern at all. But I do use white fleshed or purple fleshed sweet potatoes most of the time when I eat potatoes, finding that they work great in most recipes, even those that call for plain potatoes.
          .
          Sorry I can’t give more evidence backed thoughts than that. Maybe someone else will jump in and offer some ideas too.

  20. I agree that we need more clarity and agreement between whole plant based nutrition experts on the health benefits and dangers of potatoes. How can there be such opposing views on a staple whole food? Australian Andrew Taylor recently successfully completed a year of eating only potatoes and reports only positive mental and physical health benefits. Many are now following his inspiring example. Do they need to know more about the long term dangers of glycoalkaloids?

    http://www.spudfit.com/

  21. Potatoes: The perfect food – John McDougall MD https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0PgBL8f87FE

    McDougall’s Moments: In Defense of the Potato https://www.drmcdougall.com/health/education/videos/mcdougalls-moments/potato/

    Any critics please note that Dr.McDougall had a massive stroke at the age of eighteen on a standard diet. He is now age seventy.

    Personally, I have been consuming a fair amount of white potatoes each day for years, microwaved more recently. The gold / special brand is delicious. You can tell the peel is good because it is delicious as well. Other types of potato often have bitter tasting peel (likely due to glycoalkaloids) ….let your taste buds decide whether the peel is good for you, likely sometimes yes, sometimes no.

    I enjoy white potatoes as they are savoury. Sometimes I specifically want sweet potatoes. On a high carb, low fat plant-based diet, I trust my body directs me to the foods and nutrition best suited according to my daily energy output.

    https://www.drmcdougall.com/misc/2008nl/may/potato.htm

    *Potatoes are consumed by more of the world’s population than any other vegetable (in distinction to grains). Corn is mainly used for animal feed.

    NB. Remember, Greger shared the science demonstrating that glyphosate (not RoundUp) had very little toxic effect in humans.

    https://www.drmcdougall.com/2013/08/31/gmo-foods-a-potentially-disastrous-distraction/

  22. I just watched this video regarding baked potatoes. it wasn’t specific about which potatoes sweet or russet or otherwise. I’ve always been told that most of the nutrition is in the skin. is that no longer true? should we no longer eat the skin or bake potatoes? very confused

    1. Charles,
      Thank you for your question. Dr G recommends sweet potatoes over white potatoes since they are more nutritious and no toxin. If you can’t give up white potatoes, peel it to remove 75% of the toxin. There may be more nutrition in the peel, but also more toxin. Here is the video on sweet potatoes. You can click the sources cited link below the video to see the actual studies. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/toxins-in-sweet-potatoes/

  23. This was the best video I could find for my question. I’ve been doing the potato hack for a few weeks now (basically eat nothing but white potatoes). I did a quick blood test for ketones and found that I had 0.4 which is almost in a state of ketosis. I know i’m at a calorie deficit, but i’m eating 300+ carbs a day. How am I so close to ketosis? Side note – I feel as good on the potato diet as I did on ketosis (brain cleared up, joint pain gone, etc) which is why I tested for the ketones.

  24. All I will say is my Irish ancestors ate nothing but white potatoes until the famine then they fled here to the U.S. I was raised eating potatoes at every meal, and it hasn’t killed me yet. Hail, hail to the lowly spud.

  25. In his livestream, Dr.Greger said white potatoes are a green light food and more satiating than sweet potatoes, although sweet potatoes contain more nutrition and are, therefore superior. Also, the Irish population doubled when white potatoes were introduced. The peel is reported to contain the most nutrition. Dr.Greger didn’t say to avoid it. Included in my diet of rice, veggies, etc, I eat about 3 a day (plain from the microwave) for good energy levels and keeping lean, although to be most optimal I might choose buckwheat, quinoa or millet.

  26. KJGrier, RD, LD (Health Support Volunteer) says:

    “Thank you for your question. Dr G recommends sweet potatoes over white potatoes since they are more nutritious and no toxin. If you can’t give up white potatoes, peel it to remove 75% of the toxin. There may be more nutrition in the peel, but also more toxin. Here is the video on sweet potatoes. You can click the sources cited link below the video to see the actual studies.” https://nutritionfacts.org/video/toxins-in-sweet-potatoes/

    This comment above implies white potatoes are harmful, but Dr.Greger said they are a green light food. He did not state to remove the peel.

    1. Perhaps there is more info available now which had Dr.Greger changing potatoes from a red light food to a green light food, unless there is a chance I am mistaken.

  27. Thank you for the information on potatoes. In doing some independent research, I read that glycoalkaloids could be linked to inflammation/arthritic pain over a period of consumption with foods from the nightshade family. What about eddoes as they are somewhat similar to taste and consistency as regular white potatoes. I could not locate any research about them and if they contain glycoalkaloids only that they contain calcium oxalates so they need to be cooked thoroughly. Any information would be greatly appreciated.

  28. There is no sound scientific evidence that veggies in the night shade family cause any increase in disease or premature death. All available evidence support the opposite: that populations of people that consume these veggies experience less disease and premature death.

    Dr. Ben

  29. I’m slim, long-term high carb, low fat vegan for 18 years. I suffer extremely painful joints 1-3 days after eating tomatoes / oil / coconut sugar / more than a bare minimal amount of bell pepper. All good without, including plenty of potatoes (I haven’t experimented with eggplant or other nightshades). Dr Greger said 1 in 20 report their joint pain reduced when eliminating nightshade veggies (they’re otherwise health promoting). Perhaps you could try the eddoes and see if your symptoms change. Actually, they don’t seem to be in the nightshade family, as far as I can gather.

  30. There ist some confusion in the YouTube Community because of two different recommendations of Dr. Greger on white potatoes. In this video he says the toxicity shown in studies should no longer be ignored and potatoes are a red light food. In his latest Q&A he says white potatoes are healthy but sweet potatoes are better.
    Healthy or toxic?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This