How Much Exercise Is Too Much?
How much exercise is too much? There doesn’t appear to be any studies on the longevity of marathon or triathalon runners, but this study in which more than a thousand joggers were followed for up to a dozen years is able to offer some insight.
Surprisingly, the “light” joggers appeared to have the lowest mortality rates. Moderate joggers had a worse mortality rate than light joggers. They still did better than that of sedentary nonjoggers, but strenuous joggers did not. There wasn’t a significant difference in death rates between those jogging more than 4 hours a week and those not jogging at all. So the death versus jogging intensity graph was a U-shaped curve, with the lowest mortality bottoming out among those taking it relatively easy, clocking 1 to 2.4 hours a week over no more than three days at a slow or average pace. So more may not necessarily be better.
The jogging study spurred sensationalist headlines like “Fast Running Can Kill,” but the strenuous joggers were just dying at a higher rate compared to light joggers, not compared to the general population of nonjoggers. Here’s what a meta-analysis found of all such similar studies. Yes diminishing returns but the only clear mortality bump was associated with inactivity. However there was a retrospective analysis of more than a thousand male Olympic track and field athletes that suggested that those who had
extraordinary early peak performance had lifespans shortened by almost 5 years. The regimen for peak performance may not be the same as that for optimum health and longevity. Perhaps the mantra “exercise is medicine” metaphor should be taken a step further, recognizing that like any powerful medicine there may be a safe range of dosing.
How much exercise is too much? There doesn’t appear to be any studies on the longevity of marathon or triathalon runners, but this study in which more than a thousand joggers were followed for up to a dozen years is able to offer some insight.
Surprisingly, the “light” joggers appeared to have the lowest mortality rates. Moderate joggers had a worse mortality rate than light joggers. They still did better than that of sedentary nonjoggers, but strenuous joggers did not. There wasn’t a significant difference in death rates between those jogging more than 4 hours a week and those not jogging at all. So the death versus jogging intensity graph was a U-shaped curve, with the lowest mortality bottoming out among those taking it relatively easy, clocking 1 to 2.4 hours a week over no more than three days at a slow or average pace. So more may not necessarily be better.
The jogging study spurred sensationalist headlines like “Fast Running Can Kill,” but the strenuous joggers were just dying at a higher rate compared to light joggers, not compared to the general population of nonjoggers. Here’s what a meta-analysis found of all such similar studies. Yes diminishing returns but the only clear mortality bump was associated with inactivity. However there was a retrospective analysis of more than a thousand male Olympic track and field athletes that suggested that those who had
extraordinary early peak performance had lifespans shortened by almost 5 years. The regimen for peak performance may not be the same as that for optimum health and longevity. Perhaps the mantra “exercise is medicine” metaphor should be taken a step further, recognizing that like any powerful medicine there may be a safe range of dosing.
Republishing "How Much Exercise Is Too Much?"
You may republish this material online or in print under our Creative Commons licence. You must attribute the article to NutritionFacts.org with a link back to our website in your republication.
If any changes are made to the original text or video, you must indicate, reasonably, what has changed about the article or video.
You may not use our material for commercial purposes.
You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that restrict others from doing anything permitted here.
If you have any questions, please Contact Us
