Have you seen the very recent web blitz on heavy metals (particularly thallium) in cruciferous vegetables (particularly kale)?

Image Credit: Media Mike Hazard/ flicker

Have you seen the very recent web blitz on heavy metals (particularly thallium) in cruciferous vegetables (particularly kale)?

jack p/ Originally posted in Diverticulosis: When Our Most Common Gut Disorder Hardly Existed

Answer:

A new Care2 post has surfaced about thallium poisoning and kale. A great article in VOX lays out the background. The claims that kale has high loads of thallium stem from this 2006 study, where kale was grown in soil contaminated with thallium. Apparently the author of this study was asked about its findings and he responded to the author of the VOX article stating “To get even close to toxic levels, you’d need to plant the kale in soils with high levels of the heavy metal. (Most soils only have very low levels of thallium, he told me.) Then they’d need to accumulate a lot of it in their leaves — which doesn’t always happen. Thallium is differently bound in different soils and therefore from different soils with the same thallium content, different availability of thallium was reported” 

Furthermore, one of our site users, Darryl, always finds great studies on various topics. His comment and study links on heavy metals in soils from different countries have been super helpful!

Now, someone can eat too much raw kale due to goitrogenic compounds, but cooked doesn’t seem to be a problem. Find out how many cups of kale may be too much?

It does seem that the cruciferous vegetable family is better at accumulating thallium than other vegetables, as evident by this paper and others. However, to say that all soil is contaminated and we must worry about thallium poisoning before eating our kale and cabbage seems far fetched. 

Image Credit:Media Mike Hazard/ flicker

Discuss


3 responses to “Have you seen the very recent web blitz on heavy metals (particularly thallium) in cruciferous vegetables (particularly kale)?

Commenting Etiquette

The intention of the comment section under each video and blog post is to allow all members to share their stories, questions, and feedback with others in a welcoming, engaging, and respectful environment. Off-topic comments are permitted, in hopes more experienced users may be able to point them to more relevant videos that may answer their questions. Vigorous debate of science is welcome so long as participants can disagree respectfully. Advertising products or services is not permitted.

To make NutritionFacts.org a place where people feel comfortable posting without feeling attacked, we have no tolerance for ad hominem attacks or comments that are racist, misogynist, homophobic, vulgar, or otherwise inappropriate. Please help us to foster a community of mutual respect. Enforcement of these rules is done to the best of our ability on a case-by-case basis.

  1. Reading Townsend letter, January and February 2016, Dr. Rosenbaum explains how he identified kale consuming patients with cardiac dysthymias due to thallium in organic Kale. Organic standards changed, allowing coal ash mixed in chicken manure to be considered organic. This coal ash can be very high in thallium and is taken up by cruciferous vegetables in high enough amounts to make those consuming 8-10 servings of vegetables daily quite ill. When kale consumption stopped, thallium levels fell.
    Our local organic farmers will be working with researchers to make certain that local kale is not affected.
    For now, I can no longer recommend kale from unknown organic sources to my patients.
    Buying from local farmer who does not use unknown manure source that may be contaminated with coal ash, or growing your own kale may be “work-arounds ” for this potentially serious poison in our kale due to faulty organic standards.

    http://www.townsendletter.com/FebMarch2016/thallium0216_2.html




    0
  2. Products ԝith specific environmental benefits listed ϲan bе
    bettеr than ones claiming tⲟ be green without having claimed benefits ɑt all.When tһe cleaned jewellery іs
    dry, store іt іn jewelry box сontaining velvet lining.
    These pipes are ᴡhаt maқe іt possіble for you to get water ᴡhenever уou turn ɑround the faucet,
    washing machine, hose pipes, or whatever you decide and hɑve
    within yoᥙr home.




    0
  3. If an aluminium type surface, either stucco
    oг dimpled, іt’s a goоɗ idea to not apply any polishing agent Ьecause tһiѕ сɑn damage the paint
    рlaced on aluminium surface. Ιf you’re not certaіn ߋf the kind of solution to buy for
    your cleaning, consider applying а gentle detergent
    arοund the cloth towel ɑnd use it to clean tһe stain.
    Tһeѕe pipes are what aⅼlow thɑt you get water ѡhenever you tᥙrn aroᥙnd the faucet, automatic washer,
    hose pipes, ᧐r wһatever you decide аnd һave with уouг home.




    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This