Doctor's Note

The relationship between meat and weight gain was covered in Meat and Weight Gain in the PANACEA Study (along with a response from the meat industry, Cattlemen’s Association Has Beef With Study). I have many other videos on body fat, as well as videos on thousands of other topics.

For more context, be sure to check out my associated blog posts: Diet vs. Exercise: What’s More Important? and Diet and Cellulite.

If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my videos for free by clicking here.

To post comments or questions into our discussion board, first log into Disqus with your NutritionFacts.org account or with one of the accepted social media logins. Click on Login to choose a login method. Click here for help.

  • The relationship between meat circumference and weight gain was covered in Tuesday’s video-of-the-day Meat and Weight Gain in the PANACEA Study (along with a response from the meat industry: Cattlemen’s Association Has Beef With EPIC Study). I have about a dozen other videos on body fat, and hundreds of videos on a thousand other topics.

    If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my videos for free by clicking here.

    • HemoDynamic, M.D.

      How ’bout them Apples!

      ;-}

    • HemoDynamic, M.D.

      Out with the weight and in with the Shape!

      New frool (Fruit/Tool) in my arsenal!
      Thanks as always!
      ;-}

      • Veganrunner

        Dr hemo where did Dr SJ go? I so enjoyed his input…..

        • HemoDynamic, M.D.

          Got a bit fed up with some of the comments.  He’s doing well though.
          I agree I enjoyed his input as well.

          • Veganrunner

            Dr. SJ just ignore the negative comments. Are you still coming to Southern California? 

  • Terry

    So, how do add 26″ to my height? :-)

    • Paulc

       You’ll have to do a lot of stretching, Terry. Maybe you can find a used torturer’s  rack on Ebay. The other option is of course to discipline yourself with a healthy plant-strong diet- which will no doubt be less torture that a heart attack. 

    • I took the precise 13″ off the waist you seek by doing what the good doc prescribes; drop the processed, added sugars, meat, dairy, et al, and it melts away like…butter. :)

  • Paulc

    The waist-to-height ratio will tell us if we’re overweight- But how can we use it to tell if we’re underweight? 

    •  Good question.  Maybe if your pants fall down, or if you don’t have enough muscle to do 10 pullups, or bench press your weight.

      •  Oh, oh, ten? I don’t know if I can do that many any longer! I need to re-install my pullups bar. Thanks for the reminder :^)

    •  I’ve wondered how dangerous being underweight is. But first to determine what is *truly* underweight! It’s surely different from the conventional standards. If we go by averages of the population, we’re in BiG trouble :^)

  • Bham

    Thank you Dr. Greger and the
    Jesse and Julie Rasch Foundation for a unique and much needed website based on
    nutritional evidence.  I share the link with
    those who seem to be interested and need some worthy information.

    On a lighter note, my Windows
    Internet Explorer 9 has stopped streaming your daily video.  It must be some sort of setting as I can
    stream You Tube and another user on my computer, using Internet
    Explorer9, has no problems.  Am I
    alone?  Any suggestions?

  •  http://www.unicityhealthproducts.com  all natural health products lower cholesterol, diabetes, overweight, high blood pressure really work check out the testimonials

  • CZ

    My BMI is 16.4 and my waist circumference to height ratio is 0.42. I am often told that I am too skinny. I am not putting on any weight on a vegan diet that includes little to no refined sugars. Should I still be on a vegan diet and/or how can I put on weight on this diet?

    • Toxins

      Everyone loses some weight on a vegan diet but this weight stabilizes. You do not continue to lose it unless you in a caloric deficit which I doubt is the case unless your starving. You will look skinnier then the average person but this is completely normal and healthy. I have been told I look skinnier as well when I went vegan because my facial bones were slightly more pronounced but my weight hasn’t changed in nearly 2 years

    • one4All

      Do you like Peanut Butter Sandwiches?
      You can buy Bread that is nothing but Whole Grain and Yeast
      and Peanut butter that is Nothing but Peanuts
      If you are Obsessed with ‘Purity’
      Eat an Extra FOUR every Day and you will be OK

  • Rachel

    Hight 67 inches (5ft 6In) divided by 2 = 33.5. My waist measures at 28 inches. So I am 5.5 inches under the maximum waist circumference :) I currently weigh 134 lbs, though this is not “over weight” its all about how you feel. I am currently lifting and doing cardio 20-60minutes everyday, i rarely eat meat (maybe 2x a week I’ll have chicken). Sugar however is my shameful weakness. Where i work we have free snacks available, from ice cream to cheetos. Its extremely difficult to say no to them, especially when I’m constantly asked why aren’t i eating. I don’t have sweets at home…but i do have honey and cereal and fruit. I feel like my sweet obsession is whats in my way to achieving a flat tummy.

  • one4All

    The person in the Photo is a Pumped-Up Steroid Injecting FREAK and really should NOT be considered anything but a ‘CAUTIONARY TALE’ and CERTAINLY not a role model for healthy Living.

    • Harvey

      It’s Dr Nun S Amen Ra vegan lifter record deadlift 305 kgs?

  • Lauren

    I’m currently working to lose some weight and would like to use waistline instead of BMI as the measure of my success. My waist-to-height number would be 32. However, I didn’t have that waistline even at twelve years old! So, is my body even capable of experiencing this trim waistline? Or should I shoot for my high school/college waistline of 37 instead?

    • Lauren

      So, I have lost 40 pounds in the last 5 months, which is great, but my waistline only decreased by 4 inches – 45 to 41. I am planning on losing 30 more pounds to get to an acceptable BMI level, but at the rate I am going I still won’t get anywhere close to the 32 inch waistline. Any chance that a mom of four kids can get a little more leniency in these numbers? I can even imagine 32 inches being physically possible unless I starved myself!

      • Kelly

        I’m wondering the same thing about post children bearing bodies. I’ve had three children. My BMI is on the high end of the ideal range but I still have 5 inches to lose on my waist. Being only five feet tall it gives me a 30″ waist to work for. Is it possible?

  • Susan

    I have been eating the “Dr. Gregor” way for 5 months.
    My waistline is expanding. I can no longer button my pants.
    I feel frustrated and betrayed.

    • NFModeratorKatie

      Hi Susan! Would you be willing to tell me a little more? I’m a registered dietitian and nutrition moderator for NutritionFacts.org – I’d be happy to help!

      • Lesli

        My mother has been following Dr Greger’s plant based whole foods diet for the past 4 mos and has lost a fair amount of weight. She is 78 years old and is unable to exercise due to arthritis. Her weight loss and improved health have resulted in a decrease of blood pressure rx and a discontinuance of prescribed diuretics. Despite these positives, her healthcare provider is very concerned about her weight loss citing articles and studies that show lower mortality rates for moderately overweight elderly. Understandably, my mother is confused. Should she strive to be moderately overweight or continue down the path of healthful nutrient rich diet that has resulted in loss of pounds? Thoughts? What are the reasons behind these obese-positive results?

        • Thea

          Leslie: I’m sure Moderator Katie will reply to you when she can. In the meant time, I thought I would offer some thoughts in the hopes of being helpful.
          .
          To have an accurate discussion on the topic, we’d have to really investigate the studies in question. However, even with not seeing them (and I’m not really qualified to review them anyway), my understanding is that these are poorly done studies showing reverse causation. I’m sure you have heard the well-worn phrase: association does not equal causation. In this case, it’s usually a situation of disease causing lower weight rather than lower weight causing disease. And when people get diseases, they die sooner.
          .
          That just leaves overweight seniors looking better in certain studies. However, we know that being overweight is a disease risk factor in and of itself. There is nothing to suggest, in my opinion, that being obese is a health advantage. It seems to me that your mother’s weight loss is one more advantage to her diet. If your mother were losing weight through cancer, I would agree that there is a problem. But she’s losing weight by eating healthy foods. Assuming she is getting enough calories to maintain a healthy weight, I can’t imagine how a doctor would see that as a problem.
          .
          I’m not a doctor and I don’t know your mother. But everything you described sounds very healthy to me. You did not describe your mother as going underweight. Just getting to a healthy weight. Sadly, a healthy weight has started to look too skinny in our society because we are so used to seeing fat people. I don’t know why your doctor does not understand the studies you are talking about, but I wonder if he/she is just very confused about what a healthy person looks like.
          .
          Those are my thoughts. I hope it helps.

          • Thea

            Leslie: After writing the above post to you, I just happened to come across a recent e-mail from PCRM (Physician’s Committee for Responsible Medicine) that addresses this very topic. PCRM is very responsible in the way that they evaluate and report on scientific studies. Check out this:
            .
            Overweight and Obesity Increase Risk for Early Death
            Overweight and obesity increase the risk of premature death from cancer, heart disease, and other conditions, according to a meta-analysis published online in The Lancet. Researchers examined 239 studies that tracked BMI and mortality rates for 10,625,411 participants across four continents. Those who were overweight or obese were up to three times more likely to die early from disease, compared with those with healthy BMIs, and the risk increased as BMI rose. These findings highlight the risk of all-cause mortality related to overweight and suggest the importance of preventive measures.
            .
            From: The Global BMI Mortality Collaboration. Body-mass index and all-cause mortality: individual participant-data meta-analysis of 239 prospective studies in four continents. Lancet. Published online July 13, 2016.
            .
            Maybe if you show something like this to your mom, it will make her feel better about her choices?

        • NFModeratorKatie

          Hi Lesli – I’m familiar with the idea and research behind lower mortality rates for moderately overweight elderly. However, I personally don’t see a problem if her weight loss has been completely intentional and she’s not to the point where she is now underweight. Ideally, she has a good appetite and is consuming a wide variety of whole, plant-based foods as recommended in Dr. G’s Daily Dozen. Hope your mom continues to benefit from the many wonderful “side effects” from her WFPB diet!