Testing the Dietary Compensation Theory
An elegant study is presented, testing the appetite-suppressing effects of walnuts.
Topic summary contributed by volunteer(s): Randy
It’s not what we eat, but what we absorb. That’s why experiments showing that the sulforaphane from broccoli and broccoli sprouts can make it into breast tissue it critical for explaining how crucifers may help with breast cancer protection.
Too much nutrient absorption can sometimes be a problem though. Meeting iron needs through plant-based foods (non-heme iron) may help reduce excess iron risk (see also here). Avoiding too much iron absorption from supplements is especially important for non-anemic, pregnant women.
The allium vegetables, which include garlic and onions, may help us absorb minerals. Eating flax could also help nourish our good bacteria that in turn can aid with phytonutrient absorption. Dressings or toppings with healthy fats from nuts or seeds can help maximize phytonutrient absorption when we eat a salad.
Nutrient absorption may differ among foods. For example, calcium from broccoli and kale may be absorbed almost twice as well as calcium from milk.
Most people cannot absorb more than 1.5 micrograms of Vitamin B12 before the body can take more four to six hours later. The body absorbs B12 in such a way that the most cost-effective way to take B12 may be through one 2500 microgram sublingual, chewable, or liquid supplement of cyanocobalamin once a week. It may be better for your health to take the B12 from a supplement or fortified food instead of an animal source.
Phytosterols, which may help reduce cholesterol, are better absorbed through seeds and nuts than supplements or phytosterol-fortified spreads and beverages. Phytosterol intake does not reduce food vitamin absorption.
Anyone predisposed to oxalate absorption may want to avoid beets, which have high oxalate levels, as a plant-based nitrate source. Two spices with potential benefits are turmeric and cinnamon, but because of the soluble oxalate that can be absorbed, turmeric intake should be no more than one teaspoon per day. Since the oxalate in cinnamon is not as easily absorbed, most people can probably take up to a few teaspoons a day.
Macronutrient absorption of certain foods may also influence satiety. A study showed the fat absorption from walnuts to be filling enough to possibly help with daily overall calorie reduction. Research suggests that adding nuts and nut butters to one’s diet doesn’t lead to significant weight gain.
To maximize Vitamin D absorption, researchers have suggested that Vitamin D supplements are best taken with the largest meal of the day.
If you drink calcium-fortified soymilk, shaking the container before you drink the soymilk helps you optimize calcium absorption. Some phytonutrients are better absorbed if the plant foods are cooked rather than raw, and vice-versa. So, to best benefit your health, consider eating both raw and cooked plant foods.
For substantiation of any statements of fact from the peer-reviewed medical literature, please see the associated videos below.
Image Credit: Luke Besley / Unsplash. This image has been modified.
An elegant study is presented, testing the appetite-suppressing effects of walnuts.
If the fecal fat losses associated with undigested pieces of nuts (due to inadequate chewing), and the tedium of shelling them in the first place, help account for why nuts don’t tend to lead to weight gain, then studies on nut butters would presumably turn out differently.
A few theories have been proposed as to why nuts don’t appear to contribute to weight gain, including the “pistachio principle” and the fecal excretion theory.
Whole food sources of phytosterols, such as seeds and nuts, are likely superior to supplements, or phytosterol-fortified spreads and beverages.
Those eating plant-based diets get the most phytosterols, but there’s still room for improvement to maximize cholesterol reduction.
Phytosterols are plant-based cholesterol look-alikes in nuts and seeds that help maximize our body’s excretion of excess cholesterol.
Iron is a double-edged sword. If we don’t absorb enough, we risk anemia; but if absorb too much, we may increase our risk of cancer, heart disease, and a number of inflammatory conditions. Because the human body has no mechanism to rid itself of excess iron, one should choose plant-based (non-heme) sources, over which our body has some control.
The whole grain phytonutrient phytic acid (phytate) partially inhibits mineral absorption, but has a wide range of health-promoting properties, such as anticancer activity. By concurrently eating mineral absorption enhancers, such as garlic and onions, one can get the best of both worlds by improving the bioavailability of iron and zinc in plant foods.
Can you name a fruit whose processed juice is healthier than just eating the fruit itself?
Fruit and vegetable consumption is associated with a lower risk of heart disease. But which is more protective—raw or cooked?
The trillions of good bacteria in our gut can be thought of as an additional organ—metabolizing, detoxifying, and activating many crucial components of our diet. The formation of lignans from phytonutrient precursors found predominantly in flax seeds is one such example.
In a test tube, the broccoli phytonutrient sulforaphane appears to target breast cancer stem cells. But how do we know it’s even absorbed into the body? Have women undergoing breast reduction surgery eat some an hour before their operation, and directly measure the level in their tissues.
Young infants, and perhaps those with recurrent oxalate kidney stones, should avoid beets. But most commonly, the chief side effect is beeturia, the harmless passage of pink urine, though not all are affected—akin to the malodorous urine (“stinky pee”) that sometimes results from asparagus consumption.
Fortified foods, such as some breakfast cereals and types of nutritional yeast, can provide another cholesterol-free source of vitamin B12.
Vitamin B12 (cobalamin) supplementation can cost as little as $2 a year.
Since foods are effectively a package deal, what’s the best way to get vitamin B12 (cobalamin)?
Taking vitamin D supplements with food may be a cost-effective strategy to achieve optimum levels.
Soy milk should be shaken before pouring to get at the calcium that settles to the bottom.
There are certain phytonutrients that are absorbed better from cooked foods.
Which are the gentlest cooking methods for preserving nutrients, and which vegetables have more antioxidants cooked than raw?
Some nutrients are destroyed by cooking, but some nutrients become more absorbable.