Side Effects of Resveratrol Supplements

· ·
5/5 - (35 votes)

Resveratrol supplements may blunt some of the positive effects of exercise training.

Discuss
Republish

Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.

If you have a condition that might benefit from resveratrol supplementation, like diabetic foot ulcers, or ulcerative colitis, or menopausal pains, and want to give resveratrol a try, are there any concerns––aside from the cost, which can exceed $10 a day?

Well, although a meta-analysis of studies of resveratrol found no overall effect on LDL cholesterol levels, a couple studies found that resveratrol sometimes increased LDL levels––up to 25 percent over placebo. As cardiovascular disease is by far the leading killer of diabetics, as well as other conditions for which you might take it, if you do try resveratrol, please make sure to have your cholesterol closely monitored.

The scientific literature regarding resveratrol and cardiovascular health in general is said to be “replete with conflicting information and controversy.” There are no human studies with cardiovascular disease outcomes, but an often-overlooked study found that resveratrol caused atherosclerosis in rabbits. The study, entitled “Resveratrol promotes atherosclerosis in hypercholesterolemic rabbits,” found that the hardening of the arteries of bunnies fed dietary cholesterol was worsened by resveratrol. But, negative or null findings are often marginalized by the resveratrol research community; so, you rarely hear about them.

Though there are no long-term safety data, 450 mg a day has been considered a safe dose, at least in the short term, for a 60 kg person (that’s about 130 pounds). But supplementation at higher doses could be potentially toxic. Daily doses of resveratrol in excess of a gram commonly cause mild to moderate gastrointestinal symptoms, such as nausea, diarrhea, and abdominal pain, as well as “anal itchiness.” Unexpected renal toxicity with cases of severe kidney failure were noted in a five-gram-a-day study, but this was in the context of a cancer that is particularly hard on the kidneys.

Two studies, however, found that so-called “safe” levels of resveratrol (at 150 to 250 mg a day) may blunt some of the positive effects of exercise training. In rodents, resveratrol supplementation decreases cardiovascular risk factors, and improves cardiovascular function and physical capacity. But, when it was put to the test in older men (with an average age of 65), the exact opposite was found. Specifically, combining resveratrol with athletic training abolished the reduction in blood pressure, cholesterol, and triglycerides normally associated with exercise, had a more artery-constricting effect than a dilating one, and led to a significantly lower increase in aerobic fitness. Rodents on resveratrol get enhanced exercise performance, but in people, the resveratrol induced a 45 percent lower increase in maximum aerobic capacity compared with those taking a sugar pill. For all of their working out, the resveratrol was undercutting their efforts. An apparent impairment in peak aerobic power was also noted in young men following high-intensity interval training on resveratrol compared to placebo.

A recent review overreacted to these data by suggesting “foods containing resveratrol should not be consumed during exercise.” But to even reach the lower dose of 150 mg, you’d have to eat more than a 100 pounds of grapes a day. (Though, I suppose, if you did manage to stuff in a hundred pounds of grapes, it might indeed be a little impairing.)

The exercise impairment with resveratrol supplements does make sense, though, given its purported mechanism. Sirtuin activation by resveratrol is thought to occur via the activation of the body’s fuel gauge, AMPK, by interfering with energy production in the mitochondria powerplants in our cells. Mouse cells react by increasing mitochondria to compensate, but human cells apparently do not. So, the energy-dimming effect of resveratrol may explain why the effects of exercise are impaired.

What works in animals may not necessarily work in people. Thus, concluded one review, the hype regarding resveratrol may “turn out to be nothing more than a slight-of-hand marketing device using peer-reviewed, published, non-human research as a cover.” Although some, like Dr. Oz, have recommended resveratrol as a life-extending “miracle molecule,” given that evidence-based responses are sparse-and-controversial, such “claims, innuendo, and hyperbole” are said to be “atrocious.”

The fitness-blunting exercise study of older adults was supported in part by a manufacturer of resveratrol supplements. To their credit, the researchers responded to an angry letter from a supplement company consultant that “quote” it is our opinion that we, as scientists, have a responsibility to report what we find and not to twist our findings to fit the commercial interests “unquote.”

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Motion graphics by Avo Media

Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.

If you have a condition that might benefit from resveratrol supplementation, like diabetic foot ulcers, or ulcerative colitis, or menopausal pains, and want to give resveratrol a try, are there any concerns––aside from the cost, which can exceed $10 a day?

Well, although a meta-analysis of studies of resveratrol found no overall effect on LDL cholesterol levels, a couple studies found that resveratrol sometimes increased LDL levels––up to 25 percent over placebo. As cardiovascular disease is by far the leading killer of diabetics, as well as other conditions for which you might take it, if you do try resveratrol, please make sure to have your cholesterol closely monitored.

The scientific literature regarding resveratrol and cardiovascular health in general is said to be “replete with conflicting information and controversy.” There are no human studies with cardiovascular disease outcomes, but an often-overlooked study found that resveratrol caused atherosclerosis in rabbits. The study, entitled “Resveratrol promotes atherosclerosis in hypercholesterolemic rabbits,” found that the hardening of the arteries of bunnies fed dietary cholesterol was worsened by resveratrol. But, negative or null findings are often marginalized by the resveratrol research community; so, you rarely hear about them.

Though there are no long-term safety data, 450 mg a day has been considered a safe dose, at least in the short term, for a 60 kg person (that’s about 130 pounds). But supplementation at higher doses could be potentially toxic. Daily doses of resveratrol in excess of a gram commonly cause mild to moderate gastrointestinal symptoms, such as nausea, diarrhea, and abdominal pain, as well as “anal itchiness.” Unexpected renal toxicity with cases of severe kidney failure were noted in a five-gram-a-day study, but this was in the context of a cancer that is particularly hard on the kidneys.

Two studies, however, found that so-called “safe” levels of resveratrol (at 150 to 250 mg a day) may blunt some of the positive effects of exercise training. In rodents, resveratrol supplementation decreases cardiovascular risk factors, and improves cardiovascular function and physical capacity. But, when it was put to the test in older men (with an average age of 65), the exact opposite was found. Specifically, combining resveratrol with athletic training abolished the reduction in blood pressure, cholesterol, and triglycerides normally associated with exercise, had a more artery-constricting effect than a dilating one, and led to a significantly lower increase in aerobic fitness. Rodents on resveratrol get enhanced exercise performance, but in people, the resveratrol induced a 45 percent lower increase in maximum aerobic capacity compared with those taking a sugar pill. For all of their working out, the resveratrol was undercutting their efforts. An apparent impairment in peak aerobic power was also noted in young men following high-intensity interval training on resveratrol compared to placebo.

A recent review overreacted to these data by suggesting “foods containing resveratrol should not be consumed during exercise.” But to even reach the lower dose of 150 mg, you’d have to eat more than a 100 pounds of grapes a day. (Though, I suppose, if you did manage to stuff in a hundred pounds of grapes, it might indeed be a little impairing.)

The exercise impairment with resveratrol supplements does make sense, though, given its purported mechanism. Sirtuin activation by resveratrol is thought to occur via the activation of the body’s fuel gauge, AMPK, by interfering with energy production in the mitochondria powerplants in our cells. Mouse cells react by increasing mitochondria to compensate, but human cells apparently do not. So, the energy-dimming effect of resveratrol may explain why the effects of exercise are impaired.

What works in animals may not necessarily work in people. Thus, concluded one review, the hype regarding resveratrol may “turn out to be nothing more than a slight-of-hand marketing device using peer-reviewed, published, non-human research as a cover.” Although some, like Dr. Oz, have recommended resveratrol as a life-extending “miracle molecule,” given that evidence-based responses are sparse-and-controversial, such “claims, innuendo, and hyperbole” are said to be “atrocious.”

The fitness-blunting exercise study of older adults was supported in part by a manufacturer of resveratrol supplements. To their credit, the researchers responded to an angry letter from a supplement company consultant that “quote” it is our opinion that we, as scientists, have a responsibility to report what we find and not to twist our findings to fit the commercial interests “unquote.”

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Motion graphics by Avo Media

Doctor's Note

This is the final video in my four-part series on resveratrol. If you missed any of the others, check out: 

For more on purported anti-aging supplements, like NAD+ boosters, check out my new book, How Not to Age. (All of my proceeds are donated directly to charity.)

If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my videos for free by clicking here. Read our important information about translations here.

Subscribe to our free newsletter and receive our Daily Dozen Meal Planning Guide.

Previous Video

Resveratrol Tested for Alzheimer’s, Arthritis, and Osteoporosis

Next Video

How to Get Rid of Garlic Breath

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This