Can Gargling Prevent the Common Cold?

Can Gargling Prevent the Common Cold?
5 (100%) 7 votes

Gargling, as commonly practiced in Japan, can not only soothe a sore throat, but may even prevent one.

Discuss
Republish

Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.

Gargling is one of the best things to do to treat a sore throat. As one of my medical mentors, Dr. Michael Klaper, instructs, you take a glass of warm water; add a pinch of salt. “…Hold the glass of salt water in your hand, open your mouth, [and] take a deep breath. Tilt your head back, slide a generous mouthful to the back of your throat; and, with your mouth still open, gently breathe out through the water. Continue until the end of the breath, and then [spit it out] into the sink. Repeat until the full glass of salt water is used.”

Works wonders to soothe a sore throat when you have a cold. But I never heard of gargling to prevent a cold. Though “not popular in the Western world, [gargling] has been strongly recommended in Japan to prevent upper respiratory tract infections,” such as the common cold. However, there have been no controlled trials, and it remained unresolved as to whether gargling was really effective—until this one was published in 2005. They found a significant drop in the incidence of the common cold, but not the flu, suggesting that simple plain water gargling is effective to prevent respiratory infections among healthy people. “This virtually cost-free modality would appreciably benefit people both physically and economically around the world.”

What do they mean, “economically?” Well, most Americans, for example, report about two to three colds a year. It actually surprised me. Between medical costs and work absenteeism, we’re talking nearly 40 billion dollars a year; the common cold. So, even if you take into account the 71 seconds it took, on average, to walk to and from the sink, and gargle, and multiply that by the average wage to calculate the “cost of gargling” in wasted time, it’s still considered a cost-effective strategy.

Here’s the latest, a new study on whether it works in kids. “Gargling for Oral Hygiene and the Development of Fever in Childhood.” A total of nearly 20,000 preschoolers were observed for 20 days. And, just like the study for adults, gargling appears to lower the odds of illness by about a third. And, gargling with green tea may work better. Note: they speculate that the fact that tap water is chlorinated may have played a role. So, gargling with filtered water may be less effective. But, I would stay away from iodine solutions (such as Betadine), since one can run into the same kind of iodine overload thyroid dysfunction you can get by eating too much kelp.

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Images thanks to Dr. John McDougall, DoctorKlaper.com, and protoflux via flickr

Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.

Gargling is one of the best things to do to treat a sore throat. As one of my medical mentors, Dr. Michael Klaper, instructs, you take a glass of warm water; add a pinch of salt. “…Hold the glass of salt water in your hand, open your mouth, [and] take a deep breath. Tilt your head back, slide a generous mouthful to the back of your throat; and, with your mouth still open, gently breathe out through the water. Continue until the end of the breath, and then [spit it out] into the sink. Repeat until the full glass of salt water is used.”

Works wonders to soothe a sore throat when you have a cold. But I never heard of gargling to prevent a cold. Though “not popular in the Western world, [gargling] has been strongly recommended in Japan to prevent upper respiratory tract infections,” such as the common cold. However, there have been no controlled trials, and it remained unresolved as to whether gargling was really effective—until this one was published in 2005. They found a significant drop in the incidence of the common cold, but not the flu, suggesting that simple plain water gargling is effective to prevent respiratory infections among healthy people. “This virtually cost-free modality would appreciably benefit people both physically and economically around the world.”

What do they mean, “economically?” Well, most Americans, for example, report about two to three colds a year. It actually surprised me. Between medical costs and work absenteeism, we’re talking nearly 40 billion dollars a year; the common cold. So, even if you take into account the 71 seconds it took, on average, to walk to and from the sink, and gargle, and multiply that by the average wage to calculate the “cost of gargling” in wasted time, it’s still considered a cost-effective strategy.

Here’s the latest, a new study on whether it works in kids. “Gargling for Oral Hygiene and the Development of Fever in Childhood.” A total of nearly 20,000 preschoolers were observed for 20 days. And, just like the study for adults, gargling appears to lower the odds of illness by about a third. And, gargling with green tea may work better. Note: they speculate that the fact that tap water is chlorinated may have played a role. So, gargling with filtered water may be less effective. But, I would stay away from iodine solutions (such as Betadine), since one can run into the same kind of iodine overload thyroid dysfunction you can get by eating too much kelp.

Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.

Images thanks to Dr. John McDougall, DoctorKlaper.com, and protoflux via flickr

Doctor's Note

This is one of the landmark findings that I’m afraid no one will ever hear about because no one profits. No one, that is, except the millions of people spared from infection! I’ve taken a break from my merciless travel schedule (see all my past and future speaking dates!) to work on my 2013 batch of videos. But, whenever I’m back on the road, I hope those 71 seconds protect me from all those airport germs.

If you liked this video, you may also like The Risks and Benefits of Neti Pot Nasal Irrigation (along with my response to the question Given the “brain-eating amoeba” (Naegleria fowleri) in tap water should I sterilize my neti pot water?). Also, check out Sleep & ImmunityAntioxidant Level Dynamics, and Zinc Gel for Colds?

What else might we learn from the Japanese? See Smoking vs. Kale Juice, Bowels of the EarthAsian Paradox, Why Do Asian Women Have Less Breast Cancer? and any of my other videos on green tea or my other videos on soy.

Check out my associated blog posts for more context: Schoolchildren Should Drink More WaterProbiotics During Cold Season? and The Best Way to Prevent the Common Cold?

If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my videos for free by clicking here.

23 responses to “Can Gargling Prevent the Common Cold?

Commenting Etiquette

The intention of the comment section under each video and blog post is to allow all members to share their stories, questions, and feedback with others in a welcoming, engaging, and respectful environment. Off-topic comments are permitted, in hopes more experienced users may be able to point them to more relevant videos that may answer their questions. Vigorous debate of science is welcome so long as participants can disagree respectfully. Advertising products or services is not permitted.

To make NutritionFacts.org a place where people feel comfortable posting without feeling attacked, we have no tolerance for ad hominem attacks or comments that are racist, misogynist, homophobic, vulgar, or otherwise inappropriate. Please help us to foster a community of mutual respect. Enforcement of these rules is done to the best of our ability on a case-by-case basis.

  1. Vitashine Vegan Vitamin D3 is the best flu/cold prevention I’ve come across however taking too much over a long period of time causes insomnia.




    0



    0
  2. The yoga assana (posture) known as the “roaring lion”- it involves sticking one’s tongue out towards your chin as far as possible – also relieves sore throat and allegedly helps with a number of other problems. We wonder if the effectiveness of gargling and the roaring lion has to do with stimulating circulation in the throat.




    0



    0
  3. some may not agree, but I’ve gargled with straight Hydrogen peroxide for about 2 years now, and always! followed up with a gargle rinse of straight warm water at night and have never have had a cold since. Some say good some say bad? it works for me..




    0



    0
    1. You don’t gargle with straight hydrogen peroxide. Getting a drop of merely 30% hydrogen peroxide on the skin feels like a hot fire poker and kills the skin. You probably gargle with 3% hydrogen peroxide.




      0



      0
  4. I was wondering if it matters when you gargle with the salt water? I’m w/ Rie. As an RN the use of salt water for gargling is nothing new for sore throats, but for prevention- that is new-news.




    0



    0
  5. Hydrogen peroxide and water also helps eliminate a sore throat. But, I’m not certain if it prevents a cold. Thus far, the best remedy I’ve found to prevent a cold or the flu is common sense. Washing hands often with soap and warm water, using alcohol base sanitizers on shared equipment or while traveling, and eating vitamin A and C rich foods, and ingesting one capsule of Astragalus Root 470 mg once a day.

    Despite our housekeeper coming into our home repeatedly with colds or the flu, I’ve not been made ill, as long as I take low dosage of this herb during cold and flu season.

    On the other hand, my dentist demands the use of patients gargling with Listerine, which I find disagreeable and potentially toxic as I am already chemically sensitive and avoid such unnecessary measures.




    0



    0
  6. Been doing a salt water sinus rinse twice/day for the past 5 years and have had 2 colds in that time. One of the colds was after I’d missed 2 days of the rinse and had been working in a K12 registration department, and the other right after my father passed away..high stress. I used to get colds 3-4 times/year and it always went to my chest. At least 1/2 the time it turned to bronchitis. Think I’ll add the gargle to my routine when things are really getting passed around. It makes sense given the success of the sinus rinse.




    0



    0
    1. I asked my MD about avoiding a prolonged cough after a cold. The advice was to exercise, or at least walk around more. The idea is to avoid letting the bug settle in the chest. I tried it, I was grumpy, but it worked.




      0



      0
      1. Thanks! How much walking? Walking just to move or actually get puffing and break a sweat? I don’t imagine that you’d go to the point of exhaustion though, right?




        0



        0
  7. I’m sorry for this question but, is there a risk of taking to much iodine or not. English is not my mother tongue and sometimes it goes all to fast fore me. Can any 1 respond please




    0



    0
  8. Great study, I am going to try it too. However I can imagine 2 yea olds being able to gargle. That seems pretty advanced. Regardless, I am not two and can do it. :)




    0



    0
  9. Iodine overload? I’ve never heard of this. Does this mean that all the “nascent iodine” and all these supplements are scam and may be even dangerous?




    0



    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This