A combination of low calcium intake and low vitamin D exposure may explain higher bone fracture rates in British vegans.
Vitamin D May Explain Higher Bone Fracture Risk in Vegans
5/5 - (84 votes)
Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.
As I noted in my video on bone mineral density Do Vegans Have Lower Bone Mineral Density? vegetarians had slightly lower bone mineral density in their spines. Although the difference was basically within the margin of error for the test, if the bone quality really is compromised, it could lead to collapsed vertebrae and increased spinal fracture risk, but there is no evidence for this. The incidence of vertebral fracture was ascertained in older women who had been vegan for most of their lives—34 years on average. And despite their calcium intake being terrible, about half that of the non-vegans, and a quarter of them vitamin D deficient, the incidence of vertebral fractures was not significantly different. Although the vegans had a higher prevalence of vitamin D deficiency, and lower dietary calcium intakes, the two factors were not associated with bone loss. In fact, the annual loss in bone mineral density in the hips of vegans was less than half that of the meat-eaters, though the difference did not reach statistical significance.
Vegetarian women had not been found to be at higher risk of any kind of fractures, including wrist fractures, in this case, though among vegetarians, those who consumed the least vegetable protein intake were at the highest risk for fracture. Those who ate beans every day, or nuts, or something like veggie burgers, only had a third of the wrist fractures compared to vegetarians who only ate beans or other higher protein foods less than three times a week. So, those who consume a vegan or vegetarian diet may be at increased risk of fracture unless care is taken to ensure that an adequate quantity and variety of foods high in protein (such as whole grains, nuts, and legumes such as beans, split peas, chickpeas, or lentils) are in the diet. That’s one of the reasons in my free Daily Dozen app, I recommend whole grains and legumes every day.
Hip fractures are even more serious. Those eating legumes like beans every day reduced their risk of hip fracture by more than 60 percent, compared to 40 percent lower risk from meat protein, with plant-based meats coming in in between, with about 50 percent lower risk of hip fracture.
What’s the bottom-line on plant-based diets and bone health, according to this 2020 review? Theoretically, a long-term plant-based diet may reduce the risk of osteoporosis, but that has yet to be demonstrated. What we do know is that plant-based diets, when ensuring adequate calcium and vitamin D levels, don’t appear to have any detrimental effects on bone health. But this was published in August 2020. In November 2020, the 12-year follow-up to the study I talked about in my last video, on comparative fracture risk in vegetarians vs. non-vegetarians, was published, finding that non-meat eaters, especially vegans, had higher risks of total bone fractures, including at sites associated with osteoporosis such as hip fractures. It comes out to be about 20 more cases in vegans for every 1000 people over 10 years. So, if indeed this is cause-and-effect, eating vegan there would be an annual 1 in 500 chance of having a bone fracture that you otherwise might not have had.
Was it because they weren’t eating enough beans? Apparently not, since vegans getting more protein still apparently had higher risk. Maybe it was because they weren’t getting enough calcium? Apparently not, since vegans getting more calcium still apparently had higher risk.
What about bone and vitamin B12? If you remember, EPIC-Oxford, where the bone data come from, is the same group of British vegans who have rampant B12 deficiency. More than half the vegans were B12-deficient because they weren’t adequately supplementing with B12 or B12-fortified foods. This can lead to high homocysteine levels, which not only increase stroke risk, but may increase the activity of bone-eating cells. This was in a petri dish, but you do indeed see low bone mineral density in those born with a birth defect that leads to high homocysteine levels in the blood. Therefore, high serum homocysteine may be regarded as a factor that can reduce both bone mass and quality. But you don’t know, until you put it to the test. And homocysteine-lowering treatment failed to reduce the risk of bone fracture. So, in the end, the effect of B12 deficiency in bone health remains to be established.
Okay, so, how do we explain the higher fracture rates found among vegans? The investigators conclude that their findings suggest that bone health in vegans requires further research, but there were some clues. The elevated fracture risk, both for total fractures and for hip fractures specifically, was only significant for those under a BMI of 22.5, which is like under about 130 pounds for a woman of average height. So, part of the problem is that vegans tend to be so slender on average. Why are overweight and obese individuals protected from fractures? Think about it. They have a cushioning during a fall. There’s more of a cushion on your hips. Also, there’s an enzyme in fatty tissue that churns out estrogen, which is why women increase their breast cancer risk a percentage point for every pound they gain in adulthood. But estrogen can also have a bone-preserving effect. You can get the best of both worlds consuming soy foods, preventing bone loss while at the same time associated with lessening breast cancer risk for both estrogen receptor positive tumors and estrogen receptor negative tumors. Finally, overweight and obese individuals also may have stronger bones just from the increased weight-bearing. Carrying 100 extra pounds, you’re doing major weight bearing exercise just walking across the room! So, the risk differences they saw between vegans and meat eaters were likely at least partially due to differences in BMI.
My money, however, is on vitamin D. Great Britain is at Canadian latitudes. The sun’s rays are at such an angle during the winter months up there that the vitamin D levels among British vegans in the wintertime drop down to suboptimal levels. Ideally, we should be up around 75 nanomoles per liter or 30 nanograms per milliliter, depending on what units you’re using, which the vegans nail in the summer. It is the sunshine vitamin, after all. But in the winter, not getting the vitamin D added to dairy or found naturally in oily fish, if vegans aren’t supplementing, at that latitude during the winter, their vitamin D levels may drop too low.
Now, randomized controlled trials show that vitamin D alone doesn’t seem to reduce fracture rates, but boosting people’s vitamin D and calcium at the same time does. So, maybe it was a combination of the relatively low vitamin D and calcium intakes among the vegans that led to their higher fracture rates. We won’t know for sure until it’s actually put to the test, and when it is, you can be sure I’ll do a video.
Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.
- Shapses SA. Do we need to be concerned about bone mineral density in vegetarians and vegans? J Nutr. 2020;150(5):983-4.
- Ho-Pham LT, Vu BQ, Lai TQ, Nguyen ND, Nguyen TV. Vegetarianism, bone loss, fracture and vitamin D: a longitudinal study in Asian vegans and non-vegans. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2012;66(1):75-82.
- Thorpe DL, Knutsen SF, Beeson WL, Rajaram S, Fraser GE. Effects of meat consumption and vegetarian diet on risk of wrist fracture over 25 years in a cohort of peri- and postmenopausal women. Public Health Nutr. 2008;11(6):564-72.
- Lousuebsakul-Matthews V, Thorpe DL, Knutsen R, Beeson WL, Fraser GE, Knutsen SF. Legumes and meat analogues consumption are associated with hip fracture risk independently of meat intake among Caucasian men and women: the Adventist Health Study-2. Public Health Nutr. 2014;17(10):2333-43.
- Hsu E. Plant-based diets and bone health: sorting through the evidence. Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes Obes. 2020;27(4):248-52.
- Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353.
- Appleby P, Roddam A, Allen N, Key T. Comparative fracture risk in vegetarians and nonvegetarians in EPIC-Oxford. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2007;61(12):1400-6.
- Macêdo LLG, Carvalho CMRG, Cavalcanti JC, Freitas BJESA. Vitamin B12, bone mineral density and fracture risk in adults: A systematic review. Rev Assoc Med Bras (1992). 2017;63(9):801-9.
- Gilsing AMJ, Crowe FL, Lloyd-Wright Z, et al. Serum concentrations of vitamin B12 and folate in British male omnivores, vegetarians and vegans: results from a cross-sectional analysis of the EPIC-Oxford cohort study. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2010;64(9):933-9.
- Herrmann M, Widmann T, Colaianni G, Colucci S, Zallone A, Herrmann W. Increased osteoclast activity in the presence of increased homocysteine concentrations. Clin Chem. 2005;51(12):2348-53.
- Weber DR, Coughlin C, Brodsky JL, et al. Low bone mineral density is a common finding in patients with homocystinuria. Mol Genet Metab. 2016;117(3):351-4.
- Saito M, Marumo K. The effects of homocysteine on the skeleton. Curr Osteoporos Rep. 2018;16(5):554-60.
- Garcia Lopez M, Baron JA, Omsland TK, Søgaard AJ, Meyer HE. Homocysteine-lowering treatment and the risk of fracture: secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial and an updated meta-analysis. JBMR Plus. 2018;2(5):295-303.
- Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. Supplementary Info. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353. (DIRECT DOWNLOAD)
- Kyrgiou M, Kalliala I, Markozannes G, et al. Adiposity and cancer at major anatomical sites: umbrella review of the literature. BMJ. 2017;356:j477.
- Lydeking-Olsen E, Jens-Erik Beck-Jensen, Setchell KDR, Trine Holm-Jensen. Soymilk or progesterone for prevention of bone loss--a 2 year randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Eur J Nutr. 2004;43(4):246-57.
- Okekunle AP, Gao J, Wu X, Feng R, Sun C. Higher dietary soy intake appears inversely related to breast cancer risk independent of estrogen receptor breast cancer phenotypes. Heliyon. 2020;6(7):e04228.
- Crowe FL, Steur M, Allen NE, Appleby PN, Travis RC, Key TJ. Plasma concentrations of 25-hydroxyvitamin D in meat eaters, fish eaters, vegetarians and vegans: results from the EPIC-Oxford study. Public Health Nutr. 2011;14(2):340-6.
- Yao P, Bennett D, Mafham M, et al. Vitamin d and calcium for the prevention of fracture: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open. 2019;2(12):e1917789.
Motion graphics by Avo Media
- animal protein
- beans
- body weight
- bone fractures
- bone health
- bone loss
- bone mineral density
- breast cancer
- calcium
- Daily Dozen
- estrogen
- grains
- homocysteine
- hormones
- legumes
- lentils
- nuts
- osteoporosis
- plant protein
- Plant-Based Diets
- protein
- split peas
- stroke
- supplements
- vegans
- vegetarians
- vitamin B12
- vitamin D supplements
- women's health
Below is an approximation of this video’s audio content. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video.
As I noted in my video on bone mineral density Do Vegans Have Lower Bone Mineral Density? vegetarians had slightly lower bone mineral density in their spines. Although the difference was basically within the margin of error for the test, if the bone quality really is compromised, it could lead to collapsed vertebrae and increased spinal fracture risk, but there is no evidence for this. The incidence of vertebral fracture was ascertained in older women who had been vegan for most of their lives—34 years on average. And despite their calcium intake being terrible, about half that of the non-vegans, and a quarter of them vitamin D deficient, the incidence of vertebral fractures was not significantly different. Although the vegans had a higher prevalence of vitamin D deficiency, and lower dietary calcium intakes, the two factors were not associated with bone loss. In fact, the annual loss in bone mineral density in the hips of vegans was less than half that of the meat-eaters, though the difference did not reach statistical significance.
Vegetarian women had not been found to be at higher risk of any kind of fractures, including wrist fractures, in this case, though among vegetarians, those who consumed the least vegetable protein intake were at the highest risk for fracture. Those who ate beans every day, or nuts, or something like veggie burgers, only had a third of the wrist fractures compared to vegetarians who only ate beans or other higher protein foods less than three times a week. So, those who consume a vegan or vegetarian diet may be at increased risk of fracture unless care is taken to ensure that an adequate quantity and variety of foods high in protein (such as whole grains, nuts, and legumes such as beans, split peas, chickpeas, or lentils) are in the diet. That’s one of the reasons in my free Daily Dozen app, I recommend whole grains and legumes every day.
Hip fractures are even more serious. Those eating legumes like beans every day reduced their risk of hip fracture by more than 60 percent, compared to 40 percent lower risk from meat protein, with plant-based meats coming in in between, with about 50 percent lower risk of hip fracture.
What’s the bottom-line on plant-based diets and bone health, according to this 2020 review? Theoretically, a long-term plant-based diet may reduce the risk of osteoporosis, but that has yet to be demonstrated. What we do know is that plant-based diets, when ensuring adequate calcium and vitamin D levels, don’t appear to have any detrimental effects on bone health. But this was published in August 2020. In November 2020, the 12-year follow-up to the study I talked about in my last video, on comparative fracture risk in vegetarians vs. non-vegetarians, was published, finding that non-meat eaters, especially vegans, had higher risks of total bone fractures, including at sites associated with osteoporosis such as hip fractures. It comes out to be about 20 more cases in vegans for every 1000 people over 10 years. So, if indeed this is cause-and-effect, eating vegan there would be an annual 1 in 500 chance of having a bone fracture that you otherwise might not have had.
Was it because they weren’t eating enough beans? Apparently not, since vegans getting more protein still apparently had higher risk. Maybe it was because they weren’t getting enough calcium? Apparently not, since vegans getting more calcium still apparently had higher risk.
What about bone and vitamin B12? If you remember, EPIC-Oxford, where the bone data come from, is the same group of British vegans who have rampant B12 deficiency. More than half the vegans were B12-deficient because they weren’t adequately supplementing with B12 or B12-fortified foods. This can lead to high homocysteine levels, which not only increase stroke risk, but may increase the activity of bone-eating cells. This was in a petri dish, but you do indeed see low bone mineral density in those born with a birth defect that leads to high homocysteine levels in the blood. Therefore, high serum homocysteine may be regarded as a factor that can reduce both bone mass and quality. But you don’t know, until you put it to the test. And homocysteine-lowering treatment failed to reduce the risk of bone fracture. So, in the end, the effect of B12 deficiency in bone health remains to be established.
Okay, so, how do we explain the higher fracture rates found among vegans? The investigators conclude that their findings suggest that bone health in vegans requires further research, but there were some clues. The elevated fracture risk, both for total fractures and for hip fractures specifically, was only significant for those under a BMI of 22.5, which is like under about 130 pounds for a woman of average height. So, part of the problem is that vegans tend to be so slender on average. Why are overweight and obese individuals protected from fractures? Think about it. They have a cushioning during a fall. There’s more of a cushion on your hips. Also, there’s an enzyme in fatty tissue that churns out estrogen, which is why women increase their breast cancer risk a percentage point for every pound they gain in adulthood. But estrogen can also have a bone-preserving effect. You can get the best of both worlds consuming soy foods, preventing bone loss while at the same time associated with lessening breast cancer risk for both estrogen receptor positive tumors and estrogen receptor negative tumors. Finally, overweight and obese individuals also may have stronger bones just from the increased weight-bearing. Carrying 100 extra pounds, you’re doing major weight bearing exercise just walking across the room! So, the risk differences they saw between vegans and meat eaters were likely at least partially due to differences in BMI.
My money, however, is on vitamin D. Great Britain is at Canadian latitudes. The sun’s rays are at such an angle during the winter months up there that the vitamin D levels among British vegans in the wintertime drop down to suboptimal levels. Ideally, we should be up around 75 nanomoles per liter or 30 nanograms per milliliter, depending on what units you’re using, which the vegans nail in the summer. It is the sunshine vitamin, after all. But in the winter, not getting the vitamin D added to dairy or found naturally in oily fish, if vegans aren’t supplementing, at that latitude during the winter, their vitamin D levels may drop too low.
Now, randomized controlled trials show that vitamin D alone doesn’t seem to reduce fracture rates, but boosting people’s vitamin D and calcium at the same time does. So, maybe it was a combination of the relatively low vitamin D and calcium intakes among the vegans that led to their higher fracture rates. We won’t know for sure until it’s actually put to the test, and when it is, you can be sure I’ll do a video.
Please consider volunteering to help out on the site.
- Shapses SA. Do we need to be concerned about bone mineral density in vegetarians and vegans? J Nutr. 2020;150(5):983-4.
- Ho-Pham LT, Vu BQ, Lai TQ, Nguyen ND, Nguyen TV. Vegetarianism, bone loss, fracture and vitamin D: a longitudinal study in Asian vegans and non-vegans. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2012;66(1):75-82.
- Thorpe DL, Knutsen SF, Beeson WL, Rajaram S, Fraser GE. Effects of meat consumption and vegetarian diet on risk of wrist fracture over 25 years in a cohort of peri- and postmenopausal women. Public Health Nutr. 2008;11(6):564-72.
- Lousuebsakul-Matthews V, Thorpe DL, Knutsen R, Beeson WL, Fraser GE, Knutsen SF. Legumes and meat analogues consumption are associated with hip fracture risk independently of meat intake among Caucasian men and women: the Adventist Health Study-2. Public Health Nutr. 2014;17(10):2333-43.
- Hsu E. Plant-based diets and bone health: sorting through the evidence. Curr Opin Endocrinol Diabetes Obes. 2020;27(4):248-52.
- Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353.
- Appleby P, Roddam A, Allen N, Key T. Comparative fracture risk in vegetarians and nonvegetarians in EPIC-Oxford. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2007;61(12):1400-6.
- Macêdo LLG, Carvalho CMRG, Cavalcanti JC, Freitas BJESA. Vitamin B12, bone mineral density and fracture risk in adults: A systematic review. Rev Assoc Med Bras (1992). 2017;63(9):801-9.
- Gilsing AMJ, Crowe FL, Lloyd-Wright Z, et al. Serum concentrations of vitamin B12 and folate in British male omnivores, vegetarians and vegans: results from a cross-sectional analysis of the EPIC-Oxford cohort study. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2010;64(9):933-9.
- Herrmann M, Widmann T, Colaianni G, Colucci S, Zallone A, Herrmann W. Increased osteoclast activity in the presence of increased homocysteine concentrations. Clin Chem. 2005;51(12):2348-53.
- Weber DR, Coughlin C, Brodsky JL, et al. Low bone mineral density is a common finding in patients with homocystinuria. Mol Genet Metab. 2016;117(3):351-4.
- Saito M, Marumo K. The effects of homocysteine on the skeleton. Curr Osteoporos Rep. 2018;16(5):554-60.
- Garcia Lopez M, Baron JA, Omsland TK, Søgaard AJ, Meyer HE. Homocysteine-lowering treatment and the risk of fracture: secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial and an updated meta-analysis. JBMR Plus. 2018;2(5):295-303.
- Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Armstrong MEG, et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. Supplementary Info. BMC Med. 2020;18(1):353. (DIRECT DOWNLOAD)
- Kyrgiou M, Kalliala I, Markozannes G, et al. Adiposity and cancer at major anatomical sites: umbrella review of the literature. BMJ. 2017;356:j477.
- Lydeking-Olsen E, Jens-Erik Beck-Jensen, Setchell KDR, Trine Holm-Jensen. Soymilk or progesterone for prevention of bone loss--a 2 year randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Eur J Nutr. 2004;43(4):246-57.
- Okekunle AP, Gao J, Wu X, Feng R, Sun C. Higher dietary soy intake appears inversely related to breast cancer risk independent of estrogen receptor breast cancer phenotypes. Heliyon. 2020;6(7):e04228.
- Crowe FL, Steur M, Allen NE, Appleby PN, Travis RC, Key TJ. Plasma concentrations of 25-hydroxyvitamin D in meat eaters, fish eaters, vegetarians and vegans: results from the EPIC-Oxford study. Public Health Nutr. 2011;14(2):340-6.
- Yao P, Bennett D, Mafham M, et al. Vitamin d and calcium for the prevention of fracture: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open. 2019;2(12):e1917789.
Motion graphics by Avo Media
- animal protein
- beans
- body weight
- bone fractures
- bone health
- bone loss
- bone mineral density
- breast cancer
- calcium
- Daily Dozen
- estrogen
- grains
- homocysteine
- hormones
- legumes
- lentils
- nuts
- osteoporosis
- plant protein
- Plant-Based Diets
- protein
- split peas
- stroke
- supplements
- vegans
- vegetarians
- vitamin B12
- vitamin D supplements
- women's health
Republishing "Vitamin D May Explain Higher Bone Fracture Risk in Vegans"
Terms
You may republish this material online or in print under our Creative Commons licence. You must attribute the article to NutritionFacts.org with a link back to our website in your republication.
If any changes are made to the original text or video, you must indicate, reasonably, what has changed about the article or video.
You may not use our material for commercial purposes.
You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that restrict others from doing anything permitted here.
If you have any questions, please Contact Us
Title
Vitamin D May Explain Higher Bone Fracture Risk in Vegans
LicenseCreative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0)
Content URLDoctor's Note
If you missed the previous video, check out Do Vegans Have Lower Bone Density and More Fractures?.
I did a similar series of videos about vegetarian stroke risk, including Vegetarians and Stroke Risk Factors—Vitamin B12 and Homocystein?.
How much vitamin D do we need? Check out:
- How Much Vitamin D Should You Take?
- The Optimal Dose of Vitamin D Based on Natural Levels
- The Best Way to Get Vitamin D: Sun, Supplements, or Salons?
- The Risks and Benefits of Sensible Sun Exposure
I cover osteoporosis in much more depth in my book How Not to Age, and several upcoming videos. (As always, all proceeds go to charity.) Stay tuned!
Update: One of those newer videos is Fall Prevention Is the Most Important Thing for Preventing Osteoporosis Bone Fractures.
If you haven't yet, you can subscribe to our free newsletter. With your subscription, you'll also get notifications for just-released blogs and videos. Check out our information page about our translated resources.
Previous Video
Next Video
